I seem to have this exact problem, allthough I'm pretty sure my (brand new) Classic Controller is the original. It says Wii on the front and "Nintendo" on the plug. I have the latest version of homebrew channel along with a Snes9x 4.0.7. I've also tried a couple of other versions of Snes9x. I'm not really into the different versions of Wii, but this one is bought in Europe aby mewn - Homebrew Applications